Session Overview
Most of the hour went to one question: does Gatsby love Daisy, or the life she represents? The last ten minutes turned to whether Nick can be trusted to tell the story at all.
Does Gatsby love Daisy, or what she represents?
Most of the class read the obsession as ambition: Daisy is shorthand for the life Gatsby was locked out of. A smaller group held out for real love, pointing to the five years of letters.
Classmate: “He isn’t in love with Daisy. He’s in love with 1917.”
Professor: “Then ask what happens to the dream the moment she says yes.”
View: The green light only matters while it is out of reach.
Counter: Chapter 5 shows him happiest with Daisy actually in the room.
Where we landed: No consensus. The ambition reading held the room, but the letters kept it an open question.
Can we trust Nick to tell the story?
Most of the room said no. He calls himself one of the few honest people he has ever known, then keeps quiet about who was driving the car.
Professor: “Watch what Nick leaves out, not just what he tells you.”
Where we landed: Honest about everyone else, quiet about himself. Chapter 9 is the test case for Thursday.